Comparing Reactive vs. Preventive vs. Predictive Maintenance Strategies

Jun 10, 2024

 In the fast-paced manufacturing world, the difference between operational success and costly downtime often hinges on maintenance strategies. Surprisingly, a report from Deloitte found that unplanned downtime costs manufacturers an estimated $50 billion annually. This staggering figure highlights the critical need for more effective maintenance approaches. 

76% of manufacturing facilities use preventive maintenance, 61% employ a run-to-failure approach, and 51% utilize a computerized maintenance management system (CMMS). Reactive, predictive, and preventative maintenance each offer distinct advantages and challenges. 

This article explains the difference between the three maintenance approaches. The aim of this guide is to help you optimize your maintenance operations and prevent costly interruptions before they occur.

Understanding Reactive Maintenance Strategies

Reactive maintenance, also known as breakdown maintenance, refers to repairs that are conducted when equipment has already failed or shown signs of failing. Unlike preventive maintenance, which is scheduled and proactive, reactive maintenance is performed only after a malfunction occurs. 

This approach can be necessary in scenarios where the cost of preventive maintenance exceeds the cost of repairing a breakdown, or where the equipment does not critically affect operations.

Here are some common scenarios where reactive maintenance strategy is typically applied:

  1. Non-critical equipment: Used for items whose failure doesn’t critically impact production or safety, allowing for manageable disruptions.
  2. Cost-prohibitive Preventive Maintenance: Adopted when the cost of preventive maintenance outweighs the value of the equipment, particularly with cheaper or older machines.
  3. Simplified operations: Favored by smaller facilities or less complex operations where managing downtime is feasible without severe consequences.
  4. Residential and small-scale settings: This is common in home appliances and small office equipment, where issues are addressed as they occur rather than through regular checks.

Maintenance Strategies

3 types of Maintenance Strategies

Pros of Reactive Maintenance:

  • Lower initial costs: Less upfront investment is typically required for tools, systems, and training, as maintenance is only performed when necessary.
  • Simplicity: The maintenance approach is straightforward—fix things as they break—which can be easier to manage, especially in smaller operations or for non-critical equipment.
  • Reduced planning: It requires less planning and documentation compared to preventive or predictive maintenance strategies, which can save time in environments where operations are less critical.

Cons of Reactive Maintenance:

  • Higher long-term costs: Over time, the cost of emergency repairs, downtime, and expedited shipping for parts can exceed what preventive maintenance might cost.
  • Increased downtime: Waiting for equipment to fail often results in unplanned downtime, disrupting operations and reducing productivity. Approximately 82% of companies have encountered at least one unplanned downtime event in the past three years.
  • Shorter equipment life: Equipment that only receives attention when it fails tends to have a shorter operational lifespan due to potentially more severe damage occurring from each failure.
  • Safety risks: Reactive maintenance can pose safety risks. Failure to regularly maintain equipment may lead to unexpected breakdowns that could endanger workers.
  • Less predictable: It is difficult to predict maintenance budgets and schedules when operating reactively, as costs and timing of failures are not planned.
  • Inefficiency: The lack of regular maintenance checks can lead to a gradual decline in equipment efficiency, potentially increasing energy usage and operational costs.

Reactive Maintenance Strategy

Pros and cons of a Reactive Maintenance Strategy

Transitioning to Preventative Maintenance Strategies

Preventative maintenance is a systematic approach to maintaining equipment by performing regular checks and servicing before failures occur. This strategy is key to preventing unplanned downtime and costly emergency repairs.  In 2020, 76% of global manufacturing firms placed a high priority on preventive maintenance.

A. Why shift from Reactive to Preventative Maintenance?

Companies save 12% to 18% by choosing preventive over reactive maintenance, with every dollar spent on PM averting $5 in future costs. Reactive maintenance often leads to unexpected breakdowns and higher costs. Transitioning to preventative maintenance reduces these incidents by maintaining equipment proactively, thus ensuring higher reliability and operational efficiency. 

Implementing preventative maintenance is crucial for optimizing equipment efficiency and longevity. It minimizes the frequency of equipment failures, reduces operational costs, and enhances safety in the workplace. Preventive maintenance is preferred by 80% of maintenance personnel as a component of a comprehensive maintenance strategy.

Organizations can ensure consistent production levels and better quality outputs by adopting this proactive maintenance strategy.

B. Approaches to Preventative Maintenance:

Two of the most common preventive maintenance strategies are:

  1. Time-Based Maintenance (TBM): In the time-based approach, maintenance tasks are scheduled at fixed intervals, regardless of the equipment’s condition. This method relies on historical data and manufacturer recommendations to set maintenance intervals. For example, a textile manufacturing company might schedule the lubrication of machinery bearings every six months or the replacement of air filters in HVAC systems every quarter. This approach is straightforward and easy to implement but may lead to either over- or under-maintenance if it is not aligned closely with actual equipment wear and tear.
  2.  Usage-Based Maintenance (UBM): Alternatively, operations-based maintenance (also known as condition-based maintenance) schedules tasks based on the equipment’s actual usage and condition. Sensors and monitoring tools assess the equipment’s performance and trigger maintenance activities when certain thresholds are reached. For instance, a packaging company might replace the drive belts on their conveyor systems after every 10,000 hours of operation, or adjust the maintenance schedule based on real-time data from vibration analysis equipment. This approach tends to be more cost-effective and efficient as it targets maintenance efforts where and when they are genuinely needed.

C. Examples of Preventative Maintenance:

Below are some relevant examples:

  1. Lubrication: Regularly lubricating bearings, gears, and slides reduces friction and wear, extending their lifespan.
  2. Cleaning: Removing dust, debris, and coolant buildup from motors, fans, and control panels prevents overheating and electrical issues.
  3. Filter Replacement: Replacing air, oil, and hydraulic filters ensures optimal performance and protects sensitive components.
  4. Fastener Tightening: Checking and tightening bolts, nuts, and screws prevents misalignment, vibration, and potential component failure.
  5. Visual Inspection: Regularly inspecting belts, hoses, and wires for cracks, leaks, or signs of wear allows for timely replacement before critical failure.
  6. Vibration Analysis: Using vibration monitoring tools to detect abnormal vibrations in bearings and other critical components allows early identification of potential problems.
  7. Temperature Monitoring: Regularly monitoring the operating temperatures of motors, bearings, and hydraulic systems helps identify overheating issues before they cause damage.
  8. Oil Analysis: Periodically analyzing lubricating oil for signs of wear particles or changes in viscosity can reveal internal component wear and tear.
  9. Performance Monitoring: Tracking machine performance metrics like cycle times, output quantity, or product quality deviations can indicate potential maintenance issues.

D. Pros of Preventative Maintenance:

  • Reduced downtime: Regular maintenance can identify and rectify issues before they lead to equipment failure, minimizing unexpected downtime and avoiding disruptions in operations.
  • Cost savings: Although preventative maintenance requires upfront investment, it can significantly reduce the need for expensive emergency repairs or replacements in the long run.
  • Prolonged equipment life: Routine checks and maintenance can extend the life of equipment, ensuring it performs efficiently for its intended lifespan or even longer.
  • Boost in after-sales value: Preventative maintenance can enhance a manufacturer’s after-sales market by necessitating regular purchases of parts and inventory, thereby increasing customer touchpoints and loyalty.
  • Improved safety: Regular maintenance helps identify potential safety hazards, reduce the risk of accidents, and ensure a safer working environment for employees.

E. Cons of Preventative Maintenance

  • Initial cost: A preventative maintenance program’s initial setup and ongoing costs can be high, particularly for small businesses with limited budgets.
  • Resource allocation: Implementing a preventative maintenance schedule requires dedicating time and resources, which might otherwise be used for immediate operational needs.
  • Planning and scheduling challenges: Developing and adhering to a preventative maintenance schedule can be complex, especially for organizations with a wide range of machinery and equipment.

Maintenance Strategy

Pros and cons of a Preventive Maintenance Strategy

Advancing to Predictive Maintenance Strategies: The future

Moving from preventative to predictive maintenance strategy marks a significant evolution. Predictive maintenance leverages real-time data to predict equipment failures before they occur. This shift minimizes unnecessary maintenance and reduces downtime, optimizing operational efficiency.

A. Importance of Predictive Maintenance services

Predictive maintenance revolutionizes traditional maintenance approaches by utilizing data-driven strategies to foresee machine failures before they occur. This methodology anticipates malfunctions and strategically plans maintenance efforts to minimize downtime and optimize asset performance.

By predicting potential breakdowns, organizations can avoid the abrupt halts that come with unscheduled repairs, ensuring a seamless operational flow. This proactive approach is pivotal in maintaining continuous production and delivering services without interruption.

B. The Tech Trio: IoT, AI, and Machine Learning in Predictive Maintenance

At the core of predictive maintenance lie three technological pillars:

  • Predictive Maintenance IoT Sensors: These devices continuously gather data from equipment, offering real-time insights into machine health. By 2030, IIoT technologies are expected to generate nearly $12.6 trillion in economic value.
  • AI Analytics: Artificial intelligence processes this data, detecting anomalies and trends that may indicate impending failures.
  • Machine learning models: These models learn from vast datasets to improve fault prediction over time, becoming more accurate as they are exposed to more operational scenarios.

C. Pros of Predictive Maintenance:

  • Reduced downtime: By foreseeing and mitigating potential issues, predictive maintenance minimizes the time machines are out of operation.
  • Cost efficiency: It cuts down on unnecessary maintenance and extends the lifespan of equipment, offering a better return on investment. According to a study, predictive maintenance can lower expenses by between 10% and 40%
  • Safety enhancements: Predictive maintenance can identify safety hazards before they lead to accidents, improving workplace safety.

D. Cons of Predictive Maintenance:

  • Initial investment: The upfront cost for technology and training can be substantial.
  • Data complexity: Managing and interpreting vast amounts of data requires sophisticated software and skilled personnel.
  • Integration issues: Incorporating predictive maintenance into existing systems can sometimes be challenging and disruptive.

Maintenance Strategy

Pros and cons of a Predictive Maintenance Strategy

How to select the right maintenance strategy for your needs

Below are some important points to consider in this regard:

A. Assess equipment criticality

Evaluate how critical each piece of equipment is to your operations. High-criticality equipment might require predictive maintenance, whereas non-critical equipment might be suitable for reactive maintenance.

B. Consider operational impact

Determine the impact of downtime. Industries where downtime results in high costs or safety risks should lean towards preventive or predictive maintenance.

C. Evaluate budget constraints

Analyze your budgetary constraints. Reactive maintenance might require less initial investment but could lead to higher long-term costs due to unplanned downtime and repairs.

D. Analyze existing capabilities

Reflect on your current technological and human resource capabilities. Predictive maintenance requires more technological integration and skilled personnel to analyze data effectively.

E. Long-term strategic goals

Align the maintenance strategy with long-term operational goals. If improving operational efficiency and reducing lifecycle costs are priorities, preventive or predictive maintenance should be considered.

Optimize your maintenance strategy with Makula’s Digital Asset Management

Ready to revolutionize your maintenance approach and avoid costly downtime? Makula Digital Asset Management offers state-of-the-art tools that seamlessly integrate with your existing maintenance systems, empowering you with the data and insights needed for preventative maintenance

Don’t let unplanned downtime hinder your productivity—upgrade to Makula Digital Asset Management today and transform your maintenance processes into a predictive powerhouse!

The only CMMS offering 3D capabilities for businesses involved in selling, servicing, using, or operating machinery and assets.

With Makula’s digital solution, streamline communication and simplify operational tasks in maintenance activities .

Discover more

See our product in action.Book a free online demo!